
Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl
1919
Rate this movie
Average: 4.00 / 5
(6 votes)
Director
From the incandescent ashes and epic magniloquence of Birth of a Nation, David Wark Griffith extracts, almost as a Dantean retribution, the most fragile and whispered of his works. If his previous, controversial colossus was a historical fresco shouted at full voice, a world-unto-itself that attempted to rewrite a nation's memory with the fury of cross-cutting, Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl is its chamber-piece antithesis, a tragic haiku steeped in the opiated, sooty fogs of London's Limehouse. It is the attempt, perhaps desperate, perhaps calculated, of a cinematic titan to prove he possessed not only the strength of a mass storyteller, but also the soul of a crepuscular poet.
The film opens and closes in an atmosphere that is not merely scenography, but a state of mind. Griffith's London is not the real, topographical city of Charles Dickens, but an expressionist distillation of it, a labyrinth of the soul seemingly born from a posthumous collaboration between James Whistler and the French Symbolist poets. The fog, rendered with a pioneering and masterful use of soft focus, is not a mere atmospheric agent; it is a veil separating the world of brutal reality from that of dreams, of hope, and, finally, of tragedy. Through this diaphanous curtain move three archetypes, three figures that transcend the Victorian melodrama from which they are drawn to become universal symbols.
On one side, telluric, primordial violence: Battling Burrows (a terrifying Ernest Torrence), an alcoholic boxer and abusive father. He is no vaudeville villain; he is a force of nature, a Golem of mud and rage whose brutality knows neither logic nor redemption. He is the embodiment of Émile Zola's naturalist determinism, a product of his degraded environment, a man whose only form of expression is the blow. His home is not a hearth, but a lair, an arena where the sacrifice of innocence is performed daily.
That innocence has the ethereal, translucent face of Lillian Gish as Lucy, the "blossom" of the title. Gish does not act; she becomes an icon. Her performance is a treatise on the actor's art, anticipating the future triumphs of cinema by decades. Hers is a fragile, almost Pre-Raphaelite body upon which the violence of the world descends. Her famous closet scene, a two-minute ballet of terror, is one of the absolute pinnacles of silent cinema, and perhaps of cinema tout court. Besieged by her father, who is about to break down the door, her body contracts, flails, and twists in a spastic dance of pure panic. The attempt to force a smile onto her own lips with her fingers, a desperate gesture to placate her father's fury, is an image that sears itself into the viewer's memory. In that single gesture lies the entire poetics of the film: the desperate search for beauty in a world bent on its annihilation.
Acting as the catalyst between these two opposing forces is Cheng Huan (Richard Barthelmess), the "Yellow Man," a young Chinese immigrant who left his homeland to bring the peaceful teachings of Buddha to the savage heart of the West. Of course, the era's convention—disconcerting today—of casting a white actor in yellowface is a historical document of the production practices of the time. But once past this philological hurdle, the character emerges as a figure of surprising modernity. He is the aesthete, the contemplative, the exile of feeling who tries to build a small temple of peace and beauty—his shop filled with silks and precious objects—amidst the mud of Limehouse. His attraction to Lucy is not lust, but a form of aesthetic adoration. He sees in her not a woman, but the incarnation of a purity he thought lost, the same "blossom" he cultivates in his distant land. Their relationship is an impossible idyll, a parenthesis of tenderness destined to be crushed by reality.
Griffith orchestrates this triangle with a stunning visual sensibility. Abandoning the grandeur of the long shot, he focuses on close-ups, carving into his actors' faces like a sculptor. He uses intertitles not as mere summaries of the action, but as lyrical fragments, verses from a melancholy poem. The use of color—the sepia tinting for interior scenes, the spectral blue for the London nights, the rose for moments of fragile intimacy between Lucy and Cheng Huan—is not decorative, but dramaturgical. It is an emotional code that guides the viewer through the characters' states of mind, a technique that foreshadows the psychological use of color that would make the fortune of directors like Antonioni or Kieślowski.
Meta-textually, Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl can be read as Griffith's own aesthetic confession. After unleashing the forces of history and controversy with Birth of a Nation, the director seems almost to retreat, to take refuge in the intimate in order to explore the consequences of violence not on a nation, but on a single, fragile body. It is as if a composer of Wagnerian symphonies suddenly decided to write a Chopin piano sonata. The film is an elegy on the defeat of gentleness, a meditation on the difficulty of preserving beauty in a world dominated by brute force. Cheng Huan's mission to spread peace in the West fails miserably, and his final conversion to violence, in the tragic epilogue, is the bitter acknowledgment that the world of Battling Burrows ultimately contaminates and destroys everything.
With this work, Griffith not only creates a masterpiece of lyricism and emotional power, but also establishes a new paradigm for dramatic cinema. He demonstrates that the true epic does not necessarily reside in pitched battles or historical events, but can be found in the small space of a closet, in the tremor of a forced smile, in the shared glance of two misunderstood souls who find each other for an instant in the midst of chaos. It is a film that, more than a century later, retains its full power to move and disturb, a work that still bleeds beauty, a perfect and forever broken blossom.
Main Actors
Genres
Country
Gallery








Comments
Loading comments...