Movie Canon

The Ultimate Movie Ranking

Poster for Il Posto

Il Posto

1961

Rate this movie

Average: 5.00 / 5

(1 votes)

Director

The typewriter is not a tool. It is an organism. Its tick-tocking is not a sound. It is a heartbeat. The sheet of paper scrolling on the platen is not paper. It is the tape of a life being consumed, measured out by margins and line spacing. Ermanno Olmi, with the grace of an entomologist and the empathy of a saint, hasn't just made a film about the world of work; he has orchestrated a requiem for the individual, a symphony of alienation in which the most terrifying dystopia is not some sci-fi future, but the frighteningly tangible one of the "permanent job."

Il Posto is a work that breathes the rarefied air of those creations that deceive the viewer with their apparent simplicity. Beneath the neorealist surface, beneath the almost documentary-like chronicle of young Domenico Cantoni, who comes down from the provinces to Milan for an entrance exam at a large corporation, stirs a Kafkaesque abyss. The nameless corporation, with its labyrinthine corridors, its absurd psychological exams, and its inscrutable hierarchy, is not a mere workplace: it is The Castle. Domenico, like K. the land surveyor, is a pilgrim seeking entry to a citadel that promises security in exchange for his very essence. But unlike Kafka's hero, Domenico's tragedy is that he will, in the end, get in.

The setting is the Italian Economic Miracle, an explosion of modernity that Olmi chooses to depict not through smoking chimneys or gleaming automobiles, but through its silent, invisible human cost. The film is a desolate counterpoint to the triumphalist epic of progress. The Milan that welcomes Domenico is a city of severe geometries and impersonal spaces, a metaphysical landscape worthy of De Chirico, where the human being appears diminished, an anomaly in a world designed for function and efficiency. Olmi's camera, with a precision reminiscent of Ozu's compositions, traps its characters in architectural grids—windows, doorways, and rows of desks that foreshadow their existential prison. It is no coincidence that when Domenico and the sweet Antonietta (a disarmingly fragile Loredana Detto) find a moment of respite, they do so in a crowded café or on the chaotic streets, places where the corporation's inhuman order has not yet managed to penetrate.

Domenico, played by a non-professional, Sandro Panseri, whose awkwardness and perpetually bewildered gaze possess a piercing verisimilitude, is the archetype of Musil's "man without qualities" catapulted into a world that demands only quantity. He is a blank page on which the system will stamp its mark. His adventure is a rite of passage in reverse: not an initiation into adulthood, but a methodical stripping away of every youthful aspiration. The brief, chaste romantic interlude with Antonietta is not a love subplot; it is the final glimmer of a soul before its scheduled extinction. Their shyness, their fumbling dialogues, represent the last bastion of an authentic, not-yet-standardized humanity, one destined to be filed away like any other piece of paperwork.

It is impossible not to see Il Posto as the tragic, humanist counterpart to Billy Wilder's The Apartment, released just a year earlier. If C.C. Baxter is a cynical operator who lends out his apartment to climb the corporate ladder, Domenico is a pure soul who is simply digested by it. Wilder uses black comedy to expose the moral corruption of American capitalism; Olmi uses a muted lyricism to mourn the spiritual death caused by European bureaucracy. And where Tati, in Playtime, would transform this same landscape of glass and steel into a comic ballet on modern incommunicability, Olmi films it as a cemetery of hopes. The crowd of employees flowing in and out of the building is no different from the procession of damned souls T.S. Eliot describes crossing London Bridge in The Waste Land: "I had not thought death had undone so many."

Olmi's examination becomes almost ethological in its observation of the rites and behaviors of the older employees. The office veterans are ghosts, specters of what Domenico will become. There is the man who measures the draft, the one who complains about the noise, the one who spies on his colleagues. Each of their gestures is a tic, a conditioned reflex developed over years of captivity. The scene of the company New Year's Eve party is a masterpiece of cruelty and pity. In this brief moment of controlled chaos, the employees awkwardly attempt to recover a semblance of vitality, to ape joy. It is a melancholy carnival, a temporary liberation that only makes the return to normalcy more bitter—the return to the hum of the fluorescent lights and the industrious silence of the desks. It is here that Domenico witnesses the suicide attempt of a desperate clerk, an omen that, in his innocence, he cannot yet decipher.

And then there is the ending, one of the most devastating in cinema history. Domenico, after an agonizing wait in the limbo of the "unassigned"—a bureaucratic Purgatory—finally obtains his post. It is the desk of a clerk who has just died. His first gesture is not one of satisfaction, but of unease. He sits, small and inadequate, at an outpost that smells of death. There is no triumph. No relief. Only the beginning of the end. And in that moment, Olmi performs his sonic miracle. The noise of the mimeograph in the next room, which until then had been mere ambient sound, grows, becoming deafening, rhythmic, inexorable. It is the breathing of the Leviathan. It is the metronome that will mark the time for the rest of his existence. It is the sound of his soul being stamped, duplicated, and filed away.

In this finale, Domenico Cantoni becomes the progenitor of all future office drones of cinema and literature. He is Bartleby the Scrivener before he learns to say "I would prefer not to." He is Sam Lowry from Brazil before his fantasy takes flight from oppressive reality. He is the unnamed narrator of Fight Club before his encounter with Tyler Durden. But his tragedy is more subtle, and for that reason, more universal. There is no rebellion, no escape. There is only a silent, terrible acceptance. Il Posto teaches us that the true horror is not the exception, but the norm. Not overt tyranny, but the reassuring comfort of voluntary servitude. Olmi's film, more than sixty years after its release, remains a spectral monument, a whispered warning about the nature of compromise and the price we pay for a secure place in the world. A place that, all too often, is just an empty desk waiting for the next ghost.

Genres

Country

Gallery

Immagine della galleria 1
Immagine della galleria 2
Immagine della galleria 3
Immagine della galleria 4
Immagine della galleria 5
Immagine della galleria 6
Immagine della galleria 7
Immagine della galleria 8

Comments

Loading comments...