Movie Canon

The Ultimate Movie Ranking

Poster for Lady Bird

Lady Bird

2017

Rate this movie

Average: 4.40 / 5

(5 votes)

Director

An act of autopoiesis, a secular baptism officiated in the confines of a moving car. Christine McPherson decides she is no longer Christine. She becomes "Lady Bird". Not an alter ego, not a stage name, but an ontological declaration of intent. In this nominal choice, in this rejection of her paternal name for a near-Dadaist act of self-creation, lies the entire cosmogony of Greta Gerwig's dazzling directorial debut. A film that, beneath the polished and accessible skin of a coming-of-age comedy, hides the complexity of a Joycean Bildungsroman—if James Joyce had grown up in 2002 Sacramento, listening to the Dave Matthews Band and dreaming of an idealized East Coast as a mythological Ireland.

The topography of "Lady Bird" is, first and foremost, affective. Sacramento is not a mere setting, but a character in its own right, an ambivalent entity the protagonist loves to hate. It’s the "Midwest of California," a place defined by its very lack of definition, a geographical purgatory from which to escape in order to reach real life, which is presumed to happen elsewhere—in New York, "where writers live." In this, Gerwig captures with almost ethnographic precision the provincial anguish, that universal feeling of having been born in the wrong place, a theme that runs through American literature from Sherwood Anderson to Joan Didion, who, not coincidentally, is cited in the film as Sacramento’s most illustrious daughter. Lady Bird, like the Didion of Slouching Towards Bethlehem, is an acute observer of her environment, even if her gaze is still clouded by teenage rage and impatience. Gerwig's direction transforms the city into a series of snapshots saturated with an anticipatory nostalgia: the bridges, the Tudor houses of the wealthy neighborhoods, the Thrift Town discount store. It is a Sacramento that already exists as a memory, a landscape that will only acquire its true meaning once it has been left behind.

The film's beating heart, however, is not the escape from the provinces, but the symbiotic and fiercely conflicted relationship between Lady Bird and her mother, Marion (a Laurie Metcalf of tragic stature). Their relationship is an emotional battlefield that evokes, in its harshest dynamics, the psychological torture chambers of a Bergman film, albeit filtered through the register of screwball comedy. Their conversations are masterpieces of screenwriting, verbal duels where love and resentment, approval and ferocious criticism, trade places in the span of a single line. The opening scene, in which a moment of shared emotion while listening to an audiobook of The Grapes of Wrath descends into a furious argument culminating in Lady Bird throwing herself from the moving car, is a programmatic prologue that establishes the rules of engagement for the entire film. Marion and Christine are two sides of the same coin: stubborn, proud, incapable of admitting their own vulnerability, and bound by a love so deep it becomes almost unbearable. Gerwig dissects this dynamic with the precision of a surgeon and the empathy of one who has lived it firsthand. Every one of their clashes is a microcosm of the difficulty of separating from the one who created us, of the pain of recognizing one's own flaws in the mirror of a parent's face.

The historical context, the America of 2002-2003, is no mere ornament. It is a constant echo reverberating through the characters' lives. The Iraq War is a news item scrolling across television screens in the background, post-9/11 anxiety permeates the air, and the economic crisis befalls the McPherson family with the loss of the father's job (a sorrowful and magnificent Tracy Letts), whose depression becomes the silent counterpoint to his daughter's exuberance. This socio-cultural frame prevents the film from slipping into adolescent solipsism. Lady Bird's anxieties—college admissions, first love, losing her virginity, the fear of not being enough—are embedded in a real world, one marked by tangible economic worries and a collective uncertainty. In this sense, "Lady Bird" departs from the canon of John Hughes's cinema, to which it has been superficially compared. Where Hughes's films staged an almost mythical adolescence, isolated from the adult world, Gerwig inextricably links her protagonist's journey of growth to the cracks and tensions of the society surrounding her.

Gerwig's screenplay is a clockwork mechanism of rare perfection. The rhythm is driven by a rapid, almost elliptical editing style that assembles short scenes like diary fragments or faded Polaroids. This fragmented structure perfectly reflects the nature of adolescent memory: not a continuous flow, but a collection of intense, embarrassing, exhilarating, and painful moments. Every supporting character, from first boyfriend Danny (Lucas Hedges) to the pretentious pseudo-intellectual Kyle (a Timothée Chalamet already iconic in his bedroom nihilism), is sketched with a few, effective brushstrokes, avoiding caricature and granting each their own complex humanity. Even her best friend Julie (Beanie Feldstein) transcends the "comedic sidekick" cliché to become Lady Bird's emotional center of gravity and critical conscience.

Lady Bird's progression is not a parable of radical transformation. It is a slow, almost imperceptible process of adjusting her gaze. Her rebellion, initially loud and performative—the pink-dyed hair, the self-imposed name, the contempt for convention—gradually refines itself into a more mature understanding of herself and her roots. The real turning point is not her arrival in New York, the promised land, but a phone call home. After a night of drinking and disorientation in the metropolis, finally alone, she introduces herself on the phone with her given name: "Hi Mom and Dad, it's Christine." It is a subtle, un-shouted epiphany. The name "Lady Bird" was a suit of armor, an attempt to build an identity before she truly had one. "Christine" is the acceptance of who she is, an identity that doesn't erase Sacramento and Marion, but incorporates them. The film closes with a quote from Sister Sarah Joan, one of the wisest figures at her Catholic school: "Aren't they the same thing, love and attention?" Lady Bird, having become Christine, finally learns to pay attention. To her mother, to her city, to herself. And in that attention, she finds a form of love more profound and lasting than rebellion.

"Lady Bird" is a work that achieves the miracle of being both hyper-specific and universal at the same time. It is the portrait of one girl, in one city, in one particular year, yet its emotional resonance is timeless. It is a film about the painful beauty of detachment, about the awareness that to truly appreciate the place we come from, we must first have the courage to leave it. And that the most authentic name we can give ourselves is not the one we invent to escape, but the one we learn to inhabit with gratitude, once we have come home.

Gallery

Immagine della galleria 1
Immagine della galleria 2
Immagine della galleria 3
Immagine della galleria 4
Immagine della galleria 5
Immagine della galleria 6
Immagine della galleria 7
Immagine della galleria 8

Comments

Loading comments...