Movie Canon

The Ultimate Movie Ranking

Poster for Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

1958

Rate this movie

Average: 4.60 / 5

(5 votes)

A suffocating heat, thick as molasses, that clings to the skin and soaks into every fiber of the lavish Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer set. It is the first, and most powerful, uncredited character in "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof", a sweltering haze that is not merely climatic, but moral, psychological, existential. Richard Brooks's film, an adaptation of Tennessee Williams's Pulitzer Prize-winning play for the silver screen, pulses with this heat, sweats it from every Technicolor frame, and makes it vibrate in the voices of a cast in a state of grace. It is the heat of mendacity, the toxic vapor of unspoken truths rising from the fertile, yet rotting, lands of the Mississippi Delta.

At the heart of this emotional furnace, two celestial bodies of an almost offensive, almost mythological beauty, burn with a cold flame. Elizabeth Taylor is Maggie "the Cat," sheathed in an iconic white silk slip that seems a second skin, an armor of vulnerability. Her violet eyes are two abysses of frustration and desperate love. Paul Newman is Brick, the former football star, the broken hero drowning his pain—a nameless pain, or rather, one with a name that cannot be spoken—in a river of whiskey. His cast-iron leg and the crutch he wields like a broken scepter are the perfect metaphor for his inner paralysis. Their bedroom is not a lover's nest, but an arena, a boxing ring where her desperate need for connection collides with his glacial, alcohol-fueled refusal. It is a duel reminiscent of the claustrophobic atmosphere of a Strindberg play, but filtered through the opulent, glittering lens of Hollywood melodrama.

The greatness of Brooks's film lies in its ability to orchestrate a symphony of dissimulation. The plot is deceptively simple: a family reunion to celebrate the 65th birthday of the patriarch, "Big Daddy" Pollitt (a tectonic, monumental Burl Ives, reprising his Broadway role), who has just been diagnosed with a terminal illness. Everyone knows, except for him and his wife, Big Mama. A nest of vipers coils around this secret: the other son, Gooper, and his wife, Mae, with their brood of "no-neck monsters," are vultures circling the family fortune, champions of an unctuous and suffocating hypocrisy. But the biggest lie, the one that poisons the entire estate, is the one festering in the relationship between Brick and Maggie, and above all, the one within Brick himself.

Herein lies the genius and, simultaneously, the historic compromise of the work. The Hays Code, that great puritanical cleaver that hung over the creativity of classic Hollywood, forced Brooks and screenwriter James Poe to purge Williams's text of its incandescent core: the homosexuality, or at least the profound homoerotic bond, between Brick and his deceased friend Skipper. In the film, the cause of Skipper's suicide and Brick's subsequent collapse is nebulized into a vague betrayal involving Maggie. It is a thematic castration that, in a quintessentially cinematic paradox, ends up amplifying Brick's inner turmoil, transforming him into an even denser enigma. Absence becomes a ghostly presence; the film is built around a void that sucks everything in, a black hole of repression. What was explicit in the play becomes a phantom limb here, a pain the character feels with unspeakable violence but whose source he cannot name. And Newman, with his implosive performance, all lost gazes and silences charged with electricity, makes this void palpable, almost tangible. The film itself is forced to lie about the subject of lies, in a meta-textual hall-of-mirrors game of dizzying intelligence.

Brooks's direction is masterful in translating theatrical verbosity into pure cinematic language. Despite the unity of time and place, the film never feels static. Brooks uses the breadth of CinemaScope not to disperse the action, but to frame the loneliness of his characters, often isolating them at the edges of vast, opulent spaces. The cinematography by William Daniels, saturated with almost violent colors, creates a piercing contrast between the Pollitts' material wealth and their spiritual poverty. It’s a lesson Brooks learned from the master of melodrama, Douglas Sirk: use the glossy aesthetic of the American dream to reveal the nightmare underneath. As in Written on the Wind, the luxurious family home becomes a mausoleum of unexpressed desires and existential failures.

The film's beating heart is the titanic clash between Big Daddy and Brick in the vast basement, a Dantesque circle of hell cluttered with the bric-a-brac of the past, with memories and dust. It is here that the drama reaches its apex. Burl Ives's performance is a miracle of nuance: his vulgarity, his lust for life, his rage against the phoniness surrounding him, and his desperate search for a crumb of truth from his favorite son are overwhelming. When he bellows "Mendacity!", he isn't just condemning his family; he is disgorging his contempt upon the hypocrisy of an entire society. In this Oedipal duel, which has the power of a Dostoevskian dialogue and the brutality of an Eugene O'Neill drama, the masks crumble. Big Daddy forces Brick to confront his "disgust," and though the key word is never uttered, the sexual and emotional tension that Newman projects is almost unbearable. It is one of the greatest face-offs in cinema history, a moment where acting transcends itself to become pure, painful truth.

And then there is her, the cat. Elizabeth Taylor, reeling from a turbulent period in her personal life (her third husband, Mike Todd, had died in a plane crash shortly before filming), pours into the character of Maggie a ferocity and vulnerability that are breathtaking. She is not a mere seductress; she is a fighter, a survivor. Her sensuality is never gratuitous; it is the only weapon she has left to tear through her husband's veil of indifference. Her opening monologue, a torrent of words that breaks against Brick's silence, is a tour de force that immediately establishes the dynamic of power and desire governing their relationship. It is her determination to stay on that "hot tin roof," to not fall, that provides the film with its narrative engine and its (fragile) hope.

The ending, altered from Williams's uncompromising bitterness at the studio's behest, offers a reconciliation that might seem contrived. Brick throws the pillow onto the bed, a symbolic gesture promising an end to his abstinence and the beginning of a new, perhaps more honest, phase of their life. Yet, even in this concession to a happy ending, Brooks manages to insinuate a shadow of ambiguity. Maggie's lie about her pregnancy, conceived to secure Brick's share of the inheritance, becomes a "truth" that both choose to make real. It is not a triumph of sincerity, but a conscious decision to build a future on a shared lie, which is perhaps the only form of truth possible in the corrupt world of the Pollitts. It is a conclusion that, in its essence, remains profoundly Williamsian: salvation is found not in absolute truth, but in the fragile, desperate compassion born from a mutual understanding of one's own weaknesses. "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof" remains a blazing work, an imperfect masterpiece whose very imperfection, dictated by censorship, becomes its most profound and painful statement of purpose. A film that still burns today, with all the intensity of that torrid day on the Mississippi Delta.

Genres

Gallery

Immagine della galleria 1
Immagine della galleria 2
Immagine della galleria 3
Immagine della galleria 4
Immagine della galleria 5
Immagine della galleria 6
Immagine della galleria 7
Immagine della galleria 8

Comments

Loading comments...